Judges' Criteria
Judges' Criteria
Judge Scoring
Judges may give half-point (.5) scores to allow for finer distinctions.
Judges can provide contestant feedback. Individual scores can be shared with a contestant…if comfortable doing so. You can also refer the contestant to a board member.
No perfect scores please.
Please do not leave in the middle of the qualifier when someone is singing.
Vocal Judging (Score 1 to 10):
Song Choice – Does the song suit the contestant’s voice and style?
Pitch Accuracy – Are they on key throughout the performance?
Creativity – Do they bring a unique touch to the song?
Vocals Match Music – Does their singing fit the tempo and style of the track?
Confidence – Do they sing with assurance and control?
Stage Presence (Score 1 to 5):
Confidence – Do they command the stage?
Creativity – Is their performance original and engaging?
Performance & Expression – How well do they convey emotion and energy?
Attire – Is their outfit appropriate for their performance?
Crowd Engagement – Do they interact with the audience? (Not required but encouraged.)
Enjoyment Factor – Do they look like they’re having fun?